FTP Problem
© April 2008 Josh
Josh
Hello - I'm having a problem with a server running SCO OpenServer 5.0.7 and ftp. ftp connections used to work fine, but now I can connect to the server via ftp, I can issue type, pwd, and cd commands successfully and receive the response-- but when I issue ls, dir, get, or put commands, I get the message: "425 Can't build data connection: Invalid argument." No file configuration changes were made. The server was moved and is behind a new firewall, but as I said, I can connect and issue some commands successfully. Port 21 is open on the firewall so I can connect.
From the server, I can ftp to other sites and all commands work.
I do suspect the firewall, but I don't know why some commands work and others dont.
Got something to add? Send me email.
Inexpensive and informative Apple related e-books:
El Capitan: A Take Control Crash Course
Photos: A Take Control Crash Course
Sierra: A Take Control Crash Course
Take Control of Numbers
Take Control of Automating Your Mac
More Articles by Josh © 2012-06-30 Josh
Simplicity is prerequisite for reliability. ((Edsger W. Dijkstra)
This post tagged:
Skills Tests
Unix/Linux Book Reviews
My Unix/Linux Troubleshooting Book
This site runs on Linode
Thu Apr 17 17:37:55 2008: 4049 TonyLawrence
Yes, Josh, it is the firewall, and to understand why you need to read up on how ftp actually works - what you want is to have it work in "passive" mode.
I thought I had an article here somewhere that explained this well, but can't seem to find it.. I'll look a bit more..
Thu Apr 17 19:22:37 2008: 4052 Josh
Thanks Tony.
I did try to get passive mode to work before I wrote, but the connection disconnects at the server when switching to PASV mode. Perhaps there is a config entry I'm missing?
Josh
Thu Apr 17 19:30:41 2008: 4053 TonyLawrence
Perhaps the server can't do passive mode?
Thu Apr 17 21:06:28 2008: 4054 BruceGarlock
Doesn't port 20 need to be open at the firewall as well (ftp-data).
Fri Apr 18 01:55:11 2008: 4056 Josh
I can ftp Active and Passive behind the firewall. Since neither Active nor Passive is working on the public side, it must be a firewall issue...an odd one to be sure, but a firewall issue nonetheless.
Port 20 and 21 are both open on the firewall.
I have a local Cisco engineer looking at it.
Thanks for your comments- both of you-- you helped me narrow this down very quickly.
Josh
Fri Apr 18 02:16:32 2008: 4058 TonyLawrence
Ayup - firewall is blocking you for sure.. strange symptoms though.
Tue Oct 4 17:31:23 2011: 9902 anonymous
I am having the same problem but I am not understanding what was done to make this problem go away?
Tue Oct 4 17:46:49 2011: 9903 TonyLawrence
I don't know. Unfortunately, Josh never returned to update us.
Fri Oct 7 15:52:06 2011: 9939 anonymous
Great. Now I have guilt!
--
I don't have my notes from that time handy, but I believe that the problem was related to Active vs. Passive FTP. I'll update again as soon as I can review my notes.
Fri Oct 7 16:01:49 2011: 9940 TonyLawrence
But at the time you said you had tried Passive, so perhaps there was more to it.
Don't feel too guilty :-)
If you can find it, great. If not, we'll survive.
------------------------
Printer Friendly Version
FTP Problem Copyright © April 2008 Josh
Have you tried Searching this site?
This is a Unix/Linux resource website. It contains technical articles about Unix, Linux and general computing related subjects, opinion, news, help files, how-to's, tutorials and more.
Contact us
Printer Friendly Version