FTP Problem
I've removed advertising from most of this site and will eventually clean up the few pages where it remains.
While not terribly expensive to maintain, this does cost me something. If I don't get enough donations to cover that expense, I will be shutting the site down in early 2020.
If you found something useful today, please consider a small donation.
Some material is very old and may be incorrect today
© April 2008 Josh
Josh
Hello - I'm having a problem with a server running SCO OpenServer 5.0.7 and ftp. ftp connections used to work fine, but now I can connect to the server via ftp, I can issue type, pwd, and cd commands successfully and receive the response-- but when I issue ls, dir, get, or put commands, I get the message: "425 Can't build data connection: Invalid argument." No file configuration changes were made. The server was moved and is behind a new firewall, but as I said, I can connect and issue some commands successfully. Port 21 is open on the firewall so I can connect.
From the server, I can ftp to other sites and all commands work.
I do suspect the firewall, but I don't know why some commands work and others dont.
If you found something useful today, please consider a small donation.
Got something to add? Send me email.
Inexpensive and informative Apple related e-books:
El Capitan: A Take Control Crash Course
Photos: A Take Control Crash Course
Sierra: A Take Control Crash Course
Take Control of Numbers
Take Control of Automating Your Mac
More Articles by Josh © 2012-06-30 Josh
Simplicity is prerequisite for reliability. ((Edsger W. Dijkstra)
This post tagged:
Skills Tests
Unix/Linux Book Reviews
My Unix/Linux Troubleshooting Book
This site runs on Linode
Thu Apr 17 17:37:55 2008: 4049 TonyLawrence
Yes, Josh, it is the firewall, and to understand why you need to read up on how ftp actually works - what you want is to have it work in "passive" mode.
I thought I had an article here somewhere that explained this well, but can't seem to find it.. I'll look a bit more..
Thu Apr 17 19:22:37 2008: 4052 Josh
Thanks Tony.
I did try to get passive mode to work before I wrote, but the connection disconnects at the server when switching to PASV mode. Perhaps there is a config entry I'm missing?
Josh
Thu Apr 17 19:30:41 2008: 4053 TonyLawrence
Perhaps the server can't do passive mode?
Thu Apr 17 21:06:28 2008: 4054 BruceGarlock
Doesn't port 20 need to be open at the firewall as well (ftp-data).
Fri Apr 18 01:55:11 2008: 4056 Josh
I can ftp Active and Passive behind the firewall. Since neither Active nor Passive is working on the public side, it must be a firewall issue...an odd one to be sure, but a firewall issue nonetheless.
Port 20 and 21 are both open on the firewall.
I have a local Cisco engineer looking at it.
Thanks for your comments- both of you-- you helped me narrow this down very quickly.
Josh
Fri Apr 18 02:16:32 2008: 4058 TonyLawrence
Ayup - firewall is blocking you for sure.. strange symptoms though.
Tue Oct 4 17:31:23 2011: 9902 anonymous
I am having the same problem but I am not understanding what was done to make this problem go away?
Tue Oct 4 17:46:49 2011: 9903 TonyLawrence
I don't know. Unfortunately, Josh never returned to update us.
Fri Oct 7 15:52:06 2011: 9939 anonymous
Great. Now I have guilt!
--
I don't have my notes from that time handy, but I believe that the problem was related to Active vs. Passive FTP. I'll update again as soon as I can review my notes.
Fri Oct 7 16:01:49 2011: 9940 TonyLawrence
But at the time you said you had tried Passive, so perhaps there was more to it.
Don't feel too guilty :-)
If you can find it, great. If not, we'll survive.
------------------------
Printer Friendly Version
FTP Problem Copyright © April 2008 Josh
Have you tried Searching this site?
This is a Unix/Linux resource website. It contains technical articles about Unix, Linux and general computing related subjects, opinion, news, help files, how-to's, tutorials and more.
Contact us
Printer Friendly Version